Conscription’s not the answer

1
FIELD MARSHAL MONTGOMERY: A closeted gay bully.
FIELD MARSHAL MONTGOMERY: A closeted gay bully.


IN 2012, Matthew Harwood, writing for the Guardian, began an article about National Service with the words: ‘The corpse of long-dead idea is beginning to stir.’

Then, in 2015, Prince Harry put his oar in, suggesting a return to conscription would be great for the UK. I let out a whoop of delight when a fella responded thus on Twitter: ‘Tell you what, Prince Harry: we’ll do National Service if you and your family do proper jobs (for life), and live only off the wages.’

The issue surfaced again when, in a recent edition of EWN, columnist Leapy Lee wrote that a return to the draft in the UK would instill in youngsters ‘discipline and a respect for their fellow human beings; rescue them from the gang-infested streets and give them the opportunity to learn a trade and engage in wider life experiences.’

-- Advertisement --

With all due respect to Lee, may I suggest that mandatory conscription will do nothing to solve the UK’s burgeoning social problems, and may even exacerbate them.

Take Greece for example. Yiannis Baboulias, writing for The New Statesman this summer, pointed out that his home country – one of the last states in Europe to retain nine months’ mandatory conscription ‘suffers from exactly the same issues as other Western countries that don’t have conscription. It is divided; political polarisation has now reached extreme levels and mutual suspicion abounds.’ He added that the Greek draft ‘doesn’t seem to have the desired effect.’

Now let’s remind ourselves of what life was like for conscripts after National Service was introduced in 1947, mainly at the behest of Field Marshal Montgomery, ‘the posturing bully who was in a permanent panic of denial about his repressed homosexuality.’ He hoped ‘to use military service to mould national character towards chaste combative virility.’

These words were written by Richard Davenport-Hines in 2014. He was reviewing a book by Richard Vinen entitled National Service: Conscription in Britain 1945-1963, which revealed that, for many conscripts, their experience of life boiled down to mind-numbing square-bashing and physical and mental abuse.

Vinen wrote of the ‘hellish chaos’ of basic training: its violence, verbal savagery, the dumb misery of military drills and the horrors of bayonet practice.

‘Several young men killed themselves during training – usually by hanging from a lavatory cistern, because ‘the s**thouse’ was the only place that gave a moment’s privacy ‘ but suicide statistics seem to have been doctored by officials.’

Davenport-Hines reminded his readers that national service was disliked not only by anti-militarists and left-wingers, but by middle-of-the-road people.

‘It disrupted the lives of their sons in a period when there was full employment for the working classes. And regular army officers resented National Service, especially during its early years, because the need to train a constantly renewed stream of conscripts was dull, repetitive and diminished ‘real soldiering’.’

I, for one, am dead against conscription and its attendant brutality, and would point out a significant fact: those who are the most enthusiastic supporters of the draft were never themselves conscripted.

For the record, Spain abolished conscription in 2001 after 230 years of obligatory military service. Did this unleash waves of antisocial behaviour and cause a spike in violent crime? No, it did not.

Like
Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

EU ULTIMATUM: New Brexit plans need to be stated in 12...

BORIS JOHNSON has been warned he must give the EU new plans for Brexit by the end of the month or talks will be...

Flight Alarm: Panic On Smoke-Filled Vueling Flight

Flight VY2188 was on it's scheduled Malaga-Barcelona flight when to the horror of the passengers the cabin filled with thick smoke some twenty minutes...

Pensioner plummets seven floors while watering plants in Almeria

A PENSIONER has plummeted seven floors while watering plants at a top floor apartment in Almeria city, Spanish press is reporting.According to Spanish media,...

Storm aftermath assessment in Almanzora Valley

THE Government Sub-delegate in Almeria has visited the Almanzora Valley to see the aftermath of the severe weather first-hand.Manuel de la Fuente was in...

Marquez overtakes Hailwood with 77 GP wins

MARC MARQUEZ has become the fourth most successful rider in Grand Prix history. He took his 77th career victory at the San Marino GP to...

Arrested for seeking followers for Instagram page in Malaga

A MAN aged 22 who allegedly drove round the streets of Malaga recklessly to gain Instagram followers has been arrested. Police say he filmed himself...

Arrested for seeking followers for Instagram page in Malaga

A MAN aged 22 who allegedly drove round the streets of Malaga recklessly to gain Instagram followers has been arrested. Police say he filmed himself...

EXCLUSIVE: Armed Robbery In Los Pacos Fuengirola – Gang At Large

The popular Coviran supermarket in Los Pacos, Fuengirola, was held up at gun point late Sunday afternoon by a black masked raider wielding a...

Dawn Drug Raid Arrests In Cadiz

Alleged Drug dealer known locally in Cadiz as "El Tomate" was arrested amongst 40 other people in armed dawn raids around the coastal city...

Age Concern Marbella and San Pedro lunch

LAST week Age Concern Marbella and San Pedro held their end of summer Lunch on the patio of Aloha Pueblo in Nueva Andalucia hosted...

BREAKING NEWS: Suspected Bridge Jump Suicide in Mijas Costa

Local residents have been calling the news desk early this morning reporting a suspected suicide jump from a bridge in Mijas Costa.According to reports...

Fuengirola And Surrounding Areas Traffic Delays

Caption.Credit GoogleTraffic this morning in the Fuengirola region, especially coming into the town, is operating at 20 minute delays currently.   The A7 itself is also...

Strange animal spotted in a Mountain range in Calpe

A CROSS between a dog and a fox has been spotted in the mountain range behind Calpe. The animal was spotted by a German resident...

Tributes to Benidorm bar owner who passed away

NIGEL CONSTABLE, owner of the Company Bar in Benidorm Old Town, passed away in his sleep on Monday morning after a short spell in...

Spain Prepares For Fourth General Election November 10

Caption.Credit FilckrA fourth general election seems to be heading its way in Spain.   Prime Minister Socialist Pedro Sánchez appears to have failed in a bid...

Factual Weather Report

Whilst the weather has been a large topic in the news with the terrible storms of late, it's noted that some publications are over...

Sports centre wrecked by Tornado in Denia

 A TORNADO that ripped through Denia left devastation in its wake.Denia´s sports complex was badly damaged and may have to be completely rebuilt.Part of...

Cricket Hero Ben Stokes Smashes The Sun For Six

Caption.Credit Flickr   Ben Stokes one of England's  greatest all round cricketers of all time has gone to twitter to slam articles written about his family...

Spanish Air Force Suffer Another Loss- Death Pilots Named – 2...

Just 3 weeks after the Spanish Air Force crashed into the sea killing the pilot off the coast of La Manga, today the Air...

Spain Prepares For Fourth General Election November 10

Caption.Credit FilckrA fourth general election seems to be heading its way in Spain.   Prime Minister Socialist Pedro Sánchez appears to have failed in a bid...

Factual Weather Report

Whilst the weather has been a large topic in the news with the terrible storms of late, it's noted that some publications are over...

Cricket Hero Ben Stokes Smashes The Sun For Six

Caption.Credit Flickr   Ben Stokes one of England's  greatest all round cricketers of all time has gone to twitter to slam articles written about his family...

Stranded In Spanish Seas With No Knickers!

Caption.Credit Natalie QuinnImagine the scenario you book that dream luxury cruise that you have saved up for, it comes around to sailing and you find...

A pearl to cherish in Costa Blanca

WHILST many small towns in Costa Blanca have been devastated by the floods, Benijofar has fared a little better and has been involved in...

Spain Prepares For Fourth General Election November 10

Caption.Credit FilckrA fourth general election seems to be heading its way in Spain.   Prime Minister Socialist Pedro Sánchez appears to have failed in a bid...

Cricket Hero Ben Stokes Smashes The Sun For Six

Caption.Credit Flickr   Ben Stokes one of England's  greatest all round cricketers of all time has gone to twitter to slam articles written about his family...

Stranded In Spanish Seas With No Knickers!

Caption.Credit Natalie QuinnImagine the scenario you book that dream luxury cruise that you have saved up for, it comes around to sailing and you find...

Cancer charity ride kicks off in Malaga

THE Balcon de Europa provided the backdrop to the presentation of a charity bicycle ride that will see Bernardo Cortés and Francisco Bueno cycle...

Torrox Tourism day was a huge succes

A RECORD crowd gathered to celebrate El Día del Turista de Torrox on Saturday, further cementing the town as a haven for culture and fashion in Andalucia.According...

Motril collaboration to improve tech opportunities in Axarquia

TECHNOLOGY businesses are being invited to Axarquia to benefit from highly-skilled graduates in the area.A meeting took place on Monday 9 September between the...

Pensioner plummets seven floors while watering plants in Almeria

A PENSIONER has plummeted seven floors while watering plants at a top floor apartment in Almeria city, Spanish press is reporting.According to Spanish media,...

Storm aftermath assessment in Almanzora Valley

THE Government Sub-delegate in Almeria has visited the Almanzora Valley to see the aftermath of the severe weather first-hand.Manuel de la Fuente was in...

Stabbing suspect held in Almeria

POLICE have arrested a 43-year old man suspected of fatally stabbing a Sub-Saharan in the La Chanca-Pescaderia neighbourhood of Almeria city in the early...

Time to retune Almerian TV

THIS month is time to retune to pick up Spanish TV.The digital terrestrial television, or TDT, frequencies are changing in Almeria, meaning TVs will...

Contraband smokes in Almeria

SOME 5,000 packets of contraband cigarettes worth €25,000.That was the total amount of illicit tobacco Guardia Civil seized in less than a week during...

Spain Prepares For Fourth General Election November 10

Caption.Credit FilckrA fourth general election seems to be heading its way in Spain.   Prime Minister Socialist Pedro Sánchez appears to have failed in a bid...

Spain Prepares For Fourth General Election November 10

Caption.Credit FilckrA fourth general election seems to be heading its way in Spain.   Prime Minister Socialist Pedro Sánchez appears to have failed in a bid...

Stranded In Spanish Seas With No Knickers!

Caption.Credit Natalie QuinnImagine the scenario you book that dream luxury cruise that you have saved up for, it comes around to sailing and you find...

WEATHER UPDATE: Travel chaos as airports close down in eastern Spain...

AT LEAST THREE people have died after torrential rain, terrifying lightning storms and flash floods have swept across south-eastern SpainSpain’s acting prime minister, Pedro...

No fags or booze on Calo des Moro Beach

THE beautiful beach, Calo des Moro, has recently been made a non-smoking beach by the Santanyi town hall but they have now made the...

MasterChef Junior is filming in Mallorca

THE seventh series of Masterchef Junior is currently being filmed at the Rafa Nadal Museum in Mallorca. The children’s version of the popular Spanish TV...

Twister in Mallorca

A TORNADO hit Port Adriano yesterday afternoon as a twisting element of the storms that battered the island. Facebook was abuzz with photos and videos...

Cricket Hero Ben Stokes Smashes The Sun For Six

Caption.Credit Flickr   Ben Stokes one of England's  greatest all round cricketers of all time has gone to twitter to slam articles written about his family...

Gran trampled by camels while on holiday in Spain left with...

WHAT SHOULD have been a fun day out, including a camel ride along the beach in Fuerteventura in the Canary Islands, turned into a...

Police intercept 800kg of cocaine in international waters near Gran Canaria

THE Guardia Civil of the Canary Island have revealed that specialist teams from the Maritime Patrol department of the Tax Agency have intercepted a...

Fugitive captured in Tenerife jailed

POLICE looking for one of Scotland’s most wanted men found a simple way of catching him.UK police tipped off their Spanish counterparts that the...

Group of baby sharks spotted of Tenerife

BATHERS were shocked when a group of baby sharks descended on the beach of El Médano, in the south of Tenerife.Many bathers assumed they...

British teen stabs his parents in front of shocked tourists

A British teenager has stabbed his parents in Tenerife before jumping from a considerable height, according to reports. The incident took place on Wednesday afternoon...

BREAKING: Gibraltar to beat the UK in holding a General Election...

BEATING Boris Johnson, the Chief Minister of Gibraltar, Fabian Picardo today (Monday) handed a request to the Governor to dissolve parliament immediately.A general election...

A few rocky moments but generally Gibraltar Calling went well

THIS year’s Gibraltar Calling Festival was held at the completely new venue of Europa Point Stadium last Saturday and Sunday and there were some...

UK Parliamentarians and Gibraltar National Day

A NUMBER of British Parliamentarians have arrived in Gibraltar today (Friday) to show their support for Gibraltar’s National Day and the right of the...

Red White and Proud: A special message to the Euro Weekly...

A SPECIAL message to readers of Euro Weekly News from the Chief Minister of Gibraltar, Fabian Picardo.Come and join us in Gibraltar for our...

Illicit tobacco worth more than €30,000 seized in Gibraltar

KEEPING up with their fight against tobacco smuggling which has caused so much angst in Spain, Gibraltar customs officers have seized 750 cartons containing...

Gibraltar will host international competitors at Special Olympics National Games

THE Special Olympics were founded in 1962 by the sister of President Kennedy and are held every two years in different parts of the...

1 COMMENT

  1. Thank you. Very well put. And yes Leapy Lee did indeed dodge out of National Service. He writes about it in his book.
    He made numerous attempts and finally stated that he was gay. That did the trick.

LEAVE A COMMENT

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here